At Our Housewarming, My Husband and MIL Demanded We Give Our Apartment to His Sister, My Moms Response Shut Them Down

When Mo and Alex finally held the keys to our first home—a sunlit two‑bedroom apartment on the third floor—we felt like we’d won the lottery. The moment I set foot in that kitchen and saw dawn light spilling across the countertops, I knew this was where we’d build our life together. Although Alex and I both contributed to the mortgage, the truth was simple: this place existed because of my parents’ generosity. My dad, Mason, had handed over most of the down payment with a wink and a whispered, “Just take it, darling—no questions asked,” and my mom, Debbie, pressed a gentle kiss to my forehead as though she were sealing their love into the walls.

For three wonderful months, the apartment was ours alone. I fussed over every detail—choosing tile for the backsplash, hanging framed prints just so, and stocking the pantry with gourmet treats. Alex indulged my design flair with good humor, even as he secretly longed for a space he could stamp with his own personality. When I proposed a housewarming party, he balked, worried about the crowds. But I insisted: I wanted everyone under one roof at once, to celebrate what we’d built.

I baked for days—honey‑thyme roast chicken, goat‑cheese salad with candied pecans, and a towering cake that leaned slightly to the right but tasted divine. I donned my favorite dress and greeted each guest at the door with pride. My sister‑in‑law Katie arrived sans children—an unexpected relief, since her brood was notorious for turning any gathering into a crumb‑strewn obstacle course. My mother beamed, passing hors d’oeuvres; my dad offered steady support from the living‑room sofa.

Then Barbara, my mother‑in‑law, tapped her glass and rose, smiling with a practiced benevolence that chilled me. “Isn’t this lovely?” she began. “I’m so proud of you two. It must be so easy to save for a home when you have no distractions—no messy pets, no ragged children.” Her gaze flicked to Katie, whose exaggerated sigh said it all: Katie wanted this apartment. And in that moment, Barbara laid out her plan: Katie should move in here. Mo and Alex could decamp to my parents’ spare room until my folks came to their senses and funded a new place for me and Alex to call our own.